Copyright and Licensing
This area covers who owns what you make, what a buyer actually receives when they pay, how material that is not yours can and cannot go into your product, and what happens when someone copies you.
Key ideas
Copyright arrives with the work
Copyright is the set of exclusive rights the law gives the author of an original work: to copy, distribute, adapt, display, and perform it. It exists the moment original expression is fixed in a form that can be read back, such as a saved file, with no notice and no registration. Priya owns the copyright in her checklist the evening she saves it.
Registration with the Copyright Office is a separate, optional step with a fee. It is required before a court case over a U.S. work, and a registration made within the window the statute sets makes statutory damages and attorney fees available. The fee and the window are on this year’s figures. A copyright notice is also optional, and still useful: it removes a copier’s claim not to have known.
What copyright does not cover
Copyright protects expression, not the thing expressed. Ideas, methods, systems, facts, titles, short phrases, and blank forms are not protected. A workbook’s method can be used by anyone; the words and arrangement that teach it are yours. A template protects its text and layout, not the concept.
This cuts both ways: it limits what you own and what you can stop. Someone who teaches the same method in their own words has not copied you; someone who reproduces your pages has.
Work other people did for you
A hired writer, designer, editor, or narrator owns the copyright in what they contribute unless one of two things happens. The first is that the contribution is a work made for hire, whose copyright belongs to the person who commissioned it from the start. For a contractor that is a narrow category: the work must be specially ordered or commissioned, fall within one of the types the statute lists, and be covered by a signed written agreement calling it a work made for hire. The second is a written assignment transferring the copyright to you.
Stock images, fonts, music, and templates come under their own licenses. The license, not the purchase, decides whether commercial use, redistribution, and inclusion in a product for sale are allowed. The rights list you keep in Make the Product is the record of all of this.
What the buyer gets
A sale transfers a license, not the copyright: the buyer receives permission to do certain things with the work, and you keep the work. The usual shape for a downloadable product is use by the buyer, no redistribution, and no resale. A course or membership sells access for a period, not ownership of the material inside. A template can be licensed for the end product the buyer makes with it while resale of the template stays reserved. A separate commercial tier can allow more.
The license is written into the terms of sale, where the buyer agrees to it. What those terms must contain belongs to Terms, Refunds, and Privacy.
Using material that is not yours
Someone else’s material can appear in your product in four ways. Public domain material, where copyright has expired or never applied, can be used by anyone. Material under an open license can be used on the conditions the license attaches: credit, no commercial use, or the same license on anything built from it. Fair use allows some quotation and reuse without permission, but it is a defense decided case by case on four statutory factors, and no percentage or word count makes a use fair; the Copyright Office’s Fair Use Index collects the court decisions. Another company’s brand name can be mentioned to describe compatibility or a comparison, but not in a way that suggests the brand made or endorses your product.
Material made with generative tools
The Copyright Office’s stated position is that output a generative tool produces without sufficient human authorship is not protected by copyright, and that a registration application must disclose such material. Your own selection, arrangement, and editing of that output can be protected; the raw output is not.
When someone copies you
Most hosts and marketplaces run a takedown process built on the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). A notice goes to the host’s designated agent, listed in the Copyright Office’s directory, and must contain the elements the statute lists: identification of the work and of the copy, contact details, statements of good faith and accuracy, and a signature. The host removes the material and tells the person who posted it, who can answer with a counter-notice; the material then goes back up unless a court case follows, and that case requires registration.
Where it shows up in the process
- Choose the Product: Whether you hold a right to each piece you did not make is checked before it goes into the product.
- Make the Product: The rights list and the license decision are made while the product is built.
- Set Up the Shop: The license goes into the terms of sale the buyer accepts.
- Keep Selling: Each update adds to the rights list, and copies surface once a product sells.
Common misconceptions
- That registration or a notice is required for protection. Copyright exists when the work is fixed.
- That changing enough of someone else’s work makes it yours. An adaptation needs the owner’s permission, however much was changed.
- That educational use is automatically fair use. Purpose is one of four factors, and none decides alone.
- That buying a template or stock file transfers its copyright. It transfers a license, which sets the limits.
- That free to download means free to sell. A free file still carries its owner’s terms, which often forbid resale.
For practitioners
This area leaves three things running. The rights list is kept current as the product is updated, since each new image, quote, or contributor adds a line. Third-party licenses are kept within scope as sales grow, since some cap the end products or sales they cover. And registration is done before a dispute rather than after, since the remedies that make a case worth bringing depend on when it was filed. If you have been selling without these, check first whether every contributor’s assignment or work-for-hire agreement is in writing, then whether every stock license permits sale inside a product.
Go deeper
- Circular 1, Copyright Basics , U.S. Copyright Office
- Circular 33, Works Not Protected by Copyright , U.S. Copyright Office
- Circular 30, Works Made for Hire , U.S. Copyright Office
- Fair Use Index , U.S. Copyright Office
- Copyright and Artificial Intelligence , U.S. Copyright Office
- DMCA Designated Agent Directory , U.S. Copyright Office